Unwise intransigence

Posted: 22nd November 2016

FarmhouseIn almost any dispute, legal advice is vital so that you know when to dig your heels in and when to give ground. In one example of unwise intransigence, a 91-year-old widow’s refusal to pay a £68,000 debt that she owed to her pensioner son left her at risk of eviction from her £2 million home in Suckley.

A judge accepted that the son, Sidney Davies, 70, had been promised a barn and an acre of farmland by his father more than forty years ago before the latter’s death. The son had acted to his detriment in reliance on his father’s word, but the whole of the farm passed to the father's widow after his death. She had refused to honour her deceased husband’s promise and was ordered to pay her son £68,000 in compensation.

The debt was secured by way of a charging order against the farm. In rejecting the widow’s challenge to that order, the Court of Appeal noted that she had taken no steps to raise the necessary funds to pay the debt to her son. Combined with interest and legal costs bills, that debt had swelled to about £150,000.

Sidney had been attempting to enforce his security for more than two years and his mother had made a number of unsuccessful attempts to resist that outcome. In the circumstances, the Court gave her a month to pay the debt in full. If she failed to comply, stays on an eviction notice and an order for the sale of the farm would be lifted.